While, kennewick man has gained considerable notoriety, debates have grown over the application of the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra and whether the native americans or archaeologists have the rights to the body. Kennewick man skeleton is not subject to nagpra scientists have a statutory right to study ancient artifacts and remains such as the kennewick man the scientists may study and must submit a study plan to the department of the interior within 45 days of the august 30, 2002 ruling. The situation is important for native americans, anthropologists, archaeologists, and national law makers alike. It is consistent with the burkes commitment to both the legal and the ethical principles of nagprafederal law that allows tribes to reclaim human remains and cultural items from museums and other institutions. Nagpra after kennewick man michelle turner december 14. The potential answers that can come from the future studies of the kennewick man are so immense that i can only wait with excitement for results to come from these studies. Kennewick man was found on july 28, 1996 below lake wallula, a section of the columbia river, in washington. The kennewick man controversy has called into question the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpras ability to balance tribal, museum, and archaeological interest in ancient human remains. The 1996 discovery of kennewick man, one of the oldest north american.
May 16, 2014 according to nagpra, tribes that are not federally recognized cannot expect the repatriation of their ancestors remains. A new chapter to the controversial case of kennewick man. The kennewick man controversy top rated essay writing. Mcmanamon, nps archeology and ethnography program chief, to lt.
Mar 17, 2017 how one anthropologist balances human skeletons and human rights. Since 1990, federal law has provided for the repatriation and disposition of certain native american human remains, funerary objects, sacred objects, and objects of cultural patrimony. The native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra, pub. This means that the 8,500yearold remains are now covered by the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra. The native american graves protection and repatriation act and the.
Kennewick man may be going home, but the fallout from the case will continue to haunt our public archaeology. Native american graves protection and repatriation act of 1990 nagpra, but the events surrounding the alaska discovery are relatively unknown. The native american graves protection and repatriation act, scientific study, and kennewick man. Repatriation case studies rights and ownership of native.
As influential as it has been on archaeology, museums, and indigenous people well beyond us national borders many people consider the enactment of the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra of 1990 in the united states to. Law and bones and what the meaning of is is, steve russell10. Flood visiting associate professor of law, university of idaho college of law. The case is normally influential with regard to native us citizens, anthropologists, archaeologists, and government law. A modified version was published in the anthropology newsletter september 1997. Native american graves protection and repatriation act, or nagpra, case studies and controversy click here to read our introductory post about nagpra and museums if there are common nagpra issues between tribes and museums today, usually it is a matter of museums being unintentionally out of federal compliance museumcompiled summaries and.
The kennewick man debate is one of the most well known federal courtroom cases handling nagpra and even anthropological study. The tricity herald maintains a kennewick man virtual interpretive center with news stories, updated frequently a december 1997 letter from francis p. The case is influential for native americans, anthropologists, archaeologists, and federal law makers alike. The human skeletal remains that have come to be referred to as the kennewick man, or the ancient one, were found in july, 1996 below the surface of lake wallula, a section of the columbia river pooled behind mcnary dam in kennewick, washington. A decadelong legal case pitted scientists against native american communities and highlighted the shortcomings of the native american graves and repatriation act nagpra, designed to. T1 native american graves protection and repatriation act. Pdf kennewick man and native american graves protection and.
The figure was returned to the pueblo through a formal ceremony at the museum where both museum executives and zuni representatives were present 2. Kennewick man will be reburied, but quandaries around. Under nagpra, the tribes had the right to rebury the remains of kennewick man and to refuse. Kennewick man, owsley believes, belongs to an ancient population of seafarers who were americas original settlers. The kennewick man disputes an exploration of the kennewick man hot debate. The scientific investigation of an ancient american skeleton. Jul 05, 2014 unfortunately, in april 19, 2004 the ninth circuit court of appeals upholds us district court judge jelderks earlier decision that it cannot be identified as a native american under nagpra law.
Kennewick man is currently held at the burke museum in seattle. Based on the title and purported subject matter of the book, a little more detail about the kennewick man himself and the surrounding controversy, both legal and cultural, was expected. The kennewick man controversy assignment research writer. Kennewick man, archaeology, and the battle for native american identity by david hurst thomas, ghost singer by anna. Though it lasted many years and endured a very bumpy road, the kennewick man read.
Kennewick man, archaeology, and the battle for native american identity david hurst thomas, vine deloria jr. May 05, 2016 a long, complicated battle over 9,000yearold bones is finally over. The kennewick man finally freed to share his secrets. Nagpra is a law that, among other things, requires native american human remains found on federal or tribal land to be repatriated to lineal.
A long, complicated battle over 9,000yearold bones is. The ninth circuits assimilationist assault on the native american graves protection and repatriation act allison m. Ending with a brief analysis of the kennewick man case, this article concludes that while nagpra is a milestone in the native american struggle to gain back their stolen culture, the law alone is not enough. Simply put, native people in washington state demanded the return of kennewick man for reburial under nagpra, and scientists challenged the federal law in court, arguing for the need to study the remains. Mar 01, 2016 native american graves protection and repatriation act, or nagpra, case studies and controversy click here to read our introductory post about nagpra and museums if there are common nagpra issues between tribes and museums today, usually it is a matter of museums being unintentionally out of federal compliance museumcompiled summaries and inventories left out objects or remains, for. Passed quietly and without dissent in 1990, the native american graves protection and repatriation act. Kennewick man, archaeology, and the battle for native american identity, its all for the best. The scientific investigation of an ancient american skeleton is written for a discerning professional audience, yet the absorbing story of the remains, their discovery, their curation history, and the extensive amount of detail that skilled scientists have been able to glean from them will appeal to interested and informed. Kennewick man and native american graves protection and repatriation act. Kennewick man, known as the ancient one to native americans, has been the lightning rod for conflict between archaeologists and indigenous peoples in the united states. The return of the ancient one to the tribes is the right decision and was long overdue. Many indigenous people came to view kennewick man as a symbol for the failings of the new nagpra law.
The kennewick man finally freed to share his secrets hes the most important human skeleton ever found in north americaand here, for the first time, is his story. Code switch the 1996 discovery of kennewick man, one of the oldest north american human skeletons ever found, erupted in an. The law requires museums that receive federal funds and hold native american remains to come to an agreement with. Kennewick man perspectives on the ancient one taylor. For those who arent familiar with the kennewick man case, visit my footnote1 down. Native american graves protection and repatriation act regulationsdisposition of cultu. The kennewick man debate is one of the most well known federal courts cases coping with nagpra plus anthropological analysis. Anthropologist james chatters performed an initial examination of the skeleton on behalf of the county coroners office. Kennewick man will be reburied, but quandaries around human. Kennewick man was of european origin were an attempt to evade the law governing ownership and. Nagpra case studies and controversy plains indian museum. A long, complicated battle over 9,000yearold bones is finally. Part iii examines the complexities of nagpra, as well as its legislative history, regulations, and case law. Announcements and more from the national nagpra program.
Sep 17, 2016 kennewick man, known as the ancient one to native americans, has been the lightning rod for conflict between archaeologists and indigenous peoples in the united states. A long, complicated battle over 9,000yearold bones is finally over. It has been twelve years since the ninth circuit ended the lawsuit, ruling that kennewick man was not native american within the meaning of the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra. Kennewick man may be among the most highprofile cases of human. The kennewick man and nagpra essay native american archaeology. Such logic was not only inevitable under the current law, but, according to david hurst thomas in his new book skull wars. Problems in the repatriation of ancient skeletal remains. Nagpra, repatriation, and indigenous rights archaeological. He sued the army corps of engineers in 1994 in an attempt to gain ownership of kennewick man for further study after the army corps of engineers initially repatriated kennewick man to local native american tribes see kennewick man case. If the kennewick man qualified as native american remains, he would be given to the tribes for reburial.
The case is definitely influential regarding native us citizens, anthropologists, archaeologists, and fed law creators alike. Kennewick man and the native american graves protection and. From this point of view, the amendment suggested by mccain to nagpra law is also a necessity to avoid unwanted controversies rising from the scientific observations. It is consistent with the burkes commitment to both the legal and the ethical principles of nagprafederal law that allows tribes to reclaim. Kennewick man is the name generally given to the skeletal remains of a prehistoric. Perspectives on nagpra rights and ownership of native. University of washington press, seattle and london, 2002. Native american graves protection and repatriation act. Radiocarbon tests on bone have shown it to date from 8. On july 28, 1996, two men at columbia park in kennewick, washington, accidentally found part of a human skull on the bottom of the columbia river, about ten feet from shore. How one anthropologist balances human skeletons and human rights. The case is influential for native americans, anthropologists, archaeologists, and federal law. Remains found on federal lands fall under that 1990 law, and the repatriation of kennewick man is the responsibility of the army corps of engineers, the entity that controls the area where his. Kennewick man will be reburied, but quandaries around human remains wont.
A new beginning, not the end, for osteological analysisa hopi perspective. Due to this, the remains of kennewick man were still at the control of us army corps of engineers allowing plaintiffs scientific remains study to take. Later searches revealed a nearly complete, ancient skeleton, now known as the ancient one or kennewick man. The long term implications of the jelderks decision, susan bruning11. The kennewick man saga ended just as my book was shipping out. The corps and the tribes relied on the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra, which protects native american remains found on federal or tribal land. A highprofile lawsuit over kennewick man has led to the most extensive judicial analysis to date of the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra, the primary law affecting access to, and the ultimate disposition of, ancient human remains found in. Determination that the kennewick human skeletal remains are native american for the purposes of the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra memorandum from the departmental consulting archeologist to the assistant secretary, fish and wildlife and parks. Nagpra after kennewick man mapa blog blog or blog post. Native american graves protection and repatriation act u. The meaning of cultural affiliation and major scientific benefit in the native american graves protection and repatriation act douglas w. Alan schneider, cocounsel for the bonnichsen lawsuit, wrote this article in the late summer, 1997. A man who lived more than 9,000 years ago along the columbia river in what is now central washingtons tricities area became the center of worldwide attention and heated controversy following the 1996 discovery of his nearly complete skeleton at a riverside park in kennewick. A long, complicated battle over 9,000yearold bones.
Nagpra just celebrated 25 years as a law, and the next 25 and beyond will certainly bring more challenges. The act also applies to land transferred by the federal government to the states under the water resources department act. N2 the native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra is a u. Smart news keeping you current over 9,000 years later, kennewick man will be given a native american burial five native american nations will join together to bury his remains. In 1976, two human skeletons were found during construction work on the house of the president of uc san diego. Court ruling in kennewick man case friends of americas. Congress cannot create a law as it did for kennewick man for every skeleton in americas closest. The kennewick man controversy is one of the most well known federal court cases dealing with nagpra and anthropological research. The case is usually influential to get native people in the usa, anthropologists, archaeologists, and united states law creators alike. At around 9,500 years old, the skeletons are two of the oldest known in the americas. A decadelong legal case pitted scientists against native american communities and highlighted the shortcomings of the native american graves and repatriation act nagpra. An exploration of the kennewick man controversy the kennewick man controversy is one of the most well known federal court cases dealing with nagpra and anthropological research. Skull wars by thomas hurst 1867 words essay example.
Robson bonnichsen is perhaps the most famous scientist to speak out against nagpra and repatriation. Mar 15, 2012 kennewick man, known as the ancient one to native americans, has been the lightning rod for conflict between archaeologists and indigenous peoples in the united states. The kennewick man finally freed to share his secrets history. From these studies, presented in superabundant detail in the new book, we now have an idea who kennewick man was, how he lived, what he did and where he traveled. Kennewick man is the name generally given to the skeletal remains of a prehistoric paleoamerican man found on a bank of the columbia river in kennewick, washington, united states, on july 28, 1996. Ethical considerations and cultural perspectives haley adams the case of the kennewick man is a wellknown example in anthropological literature of the ethical issues surrounding the control and ownership of human remains. Because the kennewick man was proven to be not of native american lineage, it seems unarguable that the case be removed from under nagpra laws. The native american graves protection and repatriation act is a law that establishes the ownership of cultural items excavated or discovered on federal or tribal land after november 16, 1990. The kennewick man controversy is one of the very most well known national court cases working with nagpra and anthropological research. How one anthropologist balances human skeletons and human. The kennewick man condemnation an exploration of the kennewick man what is the answer to my homework conflict the kennewick man debate is one of the renowned federal court docket cases working with nagpra in addition to anthropological exploration.
There was no positive evidence proving that the kennewick man was a native american, therefore, the anthropologists deserved the remains of the body. In 1990, the penn museum repatriated one war god statue to the zuni pueblo in new mexico. In this intriguing work of scholarly detection, forensic anthropologist james chatters relates the story of a fossil discovery that has challenged received wisdom. His remains were found 20 years ago, in 1996, and the litigation began the same year. As curator of anthropology collections at new yorks american museum of natural history, thomas has been proactive and. The native american graves protection and repatriation act.
Since kennewick man, if governed by nagpra, clearly is not owned by the federal government, many of schneiders claimed issues and arguments seem clearly to run contrary to native american graves protection and repatriation act nagpra nagpra is a human rights law enacted as part of congresss indian trust responsibilities. A clay reconstruction of kennewick mans face was created based on the bone. Kennewick man and the native american graves protection. But under the law, museum staff and tribal nagpra delegations have started the process of implementing restorative justice to tribes. As it was, only a small space is dedicated to the 9000 year old skeletal remains of a prehistoric man found on a bank of the columbia river in kennewick, wa on. Apr 28, 2016 over 9,000 years later, kennewick man will be given a native american burial. Dec 14, 2016 ideally, we should be going beyond the letter of the law to embrace the human rights concerns that are the spirit of the law, but at a minimum we all have to know and respect the law. It is one of the most complete ancient skeletons ever found. The book recounts the history of discovery, presents a complete inventory of the. There are three books available that discuss the kennewick man case and the subject of reburial. Nagpra on trial native americans and archaeologists february 26, 1999 on july 28, 1996, a wellpreserved skeleton was discovered in the columbia river in kennewick, washington. An exploration of the kennewick man controversy the kennewick man controversy is one of the most well known federal court cases dealing with nagpra and anthrop. Kennewick man, archaeology, and the battle for native american identity.
1533 1234 1521 23 173 347 167 130 1357 1366 1360 869 1040 1200 1195 1070 555 900 664 194 149 620 849 1247 83 49 703 986 1233 1176 672 568 881 546 329 1430